IEEP’s response to the public consultation on deforestation and forest degradation

AUTHORS: Eline Blot – Marianne Kettunen

IEEP has submitted feedback to the European Commission’s public consultation on minimising the risk of deforestation and forest degradation associated with products placed on the EU market.

A Commission funded study found that between 1990 and 2008, European consumption was responsible for 10% of global deforestation associated with the production of goods and services. In this context, as announced in the European Green Deal, the Commission seeks to minimise the EU’s contribution to deforestation and forest degradation worldwide and promote the consumption of products from deforestation-free supply chains in the EU. The Commission restated its intention in both the Biodiversity Strategy for 2030 and the Farm to Fork Strategy.

IEEP welcomes the opportunity to submit its opinion to the European Commission’s public consultation survey, which covered several important aspects linked to deforestation and forest degradation associated with global value chains. However, this complementary written submission highlights two additional issues not addressed in the survey that IEEP considers of key importance for future discussions, particularly linked to the trade dimension of these problems:

The formulation of sustainability criteria and definitions for deforestation-free products; and
The role EU trade agreements and supporting processes can play in addressing deforestation and forest degradation.

Principles & sustainability criteria

The Commission is faced with a significant opportunity; by designing a binding measure to ensure that all commodities and products placed on the EU market avoid contributing to deforestation and forest degradation, the EU could lead the way in establishing common sustainability criteria which could then be implemented in a practical way, in- and outside the EU.

In this context, IEEP emphasises the need for explicit principles and criteria that are feasible to interpret and implement, in both the EU and third countries, as well as criteria that are applicable to a wide variety of commodities and products. These criteria should be built on a foundation of clear definitions of key concepts (e.g. definitions for ‘forest’, ‘deforestation’ and ‘forest degradation’) and a sensible base year. Moreover, these criteria need to be complemented by appropriate instruments ensuring chain of custody and full traceability of products.

Therefore, IEEP recommends the Commission first to take steps to explicitly outline the principle of this initiative by determining its objective. Then, as a next step, a set of criteria needs to be established to describe how the principle can be adhered to in practice. Central to the development of effective sustainability criteria is ensuring clarity on the definitions of the concepts used, particularly when referring to areas being protected.

See IEEP’s scoping study for more details on sustainability criteria for deforestation-free commodities.

Trade agreements & underpinning processes

The Commission’s proposal for the development of deforestation-free supply chains, if appropriately designed and implemented, would help to address several concerns pertaining to European consumption’s contribution to deforestation.

However, IEEP stresses that in order to prevent negative impacts of global supply chains to forest ecosystems, the Commission needs to also move forward with the implementation of the broader Green Deal agenda on ‘greening’ EU trade as this is the framework within which the future EU measure(s) will need to be implemented (e.g. enforced and monitored).

In this context, IEEP emphasises the need to make trade work for the environment by reinforcing the forestry elements in trade agreements and their underpinning processes, i.e., the Trade and Sustainable Development Chapters and Sustainability Impact Assessments (SIA); and by ensuring the coherence of the deforestation-free supply chains proposal with the upcoming legislative proposal on ‘due diligence’.

Trade and Sustainable Development (TSD) Chapter provisions for forestry could contribute to the Commission’s initiative for the development of deforestation-free supply chains in several ways. For instance, if the forestry provisions in the TSD Chapters were made to be more explicit and enforceable, violations of these provisions could be more swiftly identified and addressed.

Moreover, the overall enforcement of TSD Chapter provisions could be improved by including the implementation of the TSD Chapter under the more stringent overall FTA dispute settlement mechanism. Going further, forestry protection could be extended – beyond the TSD Chapters – by ‘unboxing’ TSD Chapter provisions and mainstreaming them into sector-specific chapters of the FTA.

Finally, for existing FTAs, the implementation of TSD Chapters should be improved upon by taking forward the foreseen trade and sustainable development-related actions under the European Green Deal (e.g. the complaints platform), including allocating dedicated resources for their delivery.

Sustainability Impact Assessments (SIA) and ex post evaluations play an essential role in underpinning trade agreements by assessing the potential economic, social and environmental implications of trade liberalisation with the results feeding directly into the negotiation and/or implementation process. Therefore, the treatment of environment and – more specific to this consultation – forest ecosystems and biodiversity is of utmost importance if this information is to feed into the FTA which grants protections to these environmental elements.

IEEP’s previous research finds that the EU SIA process is in need of more explicit guidance for and systematic and in-depth treatment of environmental aspects sectors affected by trade liberalisation. IEEP emphasises the need to update or complement the official EU SIA Guidance Handbook with more explicit guidance for assessing environmental impacts (e.g. deforestation and biodiversity) to improve the extent and robustness of environment-related analysis.

This should be complemented by continuing to develop methods and tools for assessing different environmental consequences of trade liberalisation, including improving the spatial granularity of assessments. Finally, IEEP stresses the need to allocate adequate resources for third parties carrying out the assessments, by providing an earmarked share of the budget or a clarification on minimum budget to be allocated for the environmental aspects of the overall assessment.

More info

IEEP’s response to the European Commission’s public consultation drew on a number of IEEP publications, which can be consulted via following links: Nanni, Allen, Treharne, Meredith & Bowyer (2020), Kettunen, Davey, Bodin, Gionfra & Charveriat (2020) and Kuik, Kettunen, van Vliet, Colsa & Illes (2018).

The response was compiled and submitted by Eline Blot and Marianne Kettunen. For more information on IEEP’s work on this area please contact Marianne Kettunen (mkettunen@ieep.eu).

Keuntungan Bermain di OVOPLAY Slot Gacor:

Tingkat Kemenangan Tinggi: Salah satu keuntungan utama bermain di OVOPLAY Slot Gacor adalah tingkat kemenangan yang tinggi. Ini berarti para pemain memiliki peluang lebih besar untuk memenangkan hadiah saat bermain game slot favorit mereka.

Variasi Permainan yang Luas: OVOPLAY tidak hanya menawarkan slot gacor, tetapi juga beragam permainan menarik lainnya. Dari permainan klasik hingga inovatif, ada sesuatu untuk semua orang. Ini membuat pengalaman bermain semakin seru dan tidak monoton.

Aksesibilitas Melalui OVO: Sebagai platform yang terintegrasi dengan OVO, OVOPLAY memberikan kemudahan akses dan transaksi bagi para pemain. Pembayaran dan penarikan dana menjadi lebih mudah dan cepat, menambah kenyamanan dalam bermain.

Bonus dan Promosi Menarik: OVOPLAY Slot Gacor dikenal memberikan bonus dan promosi secara teratur kepada para pemainnya. Ini bisa berupa bonus pendaftaran, putaran gratis, atau promo khusus yang menambah nilai hiburan dan peluang menang.

Desain Grafis yang Menarik: Pengalaman bermain game semakin lengkap dengan desain grafis yang menarik. OVOPLAY menawarkan visual yang memikat, menciptakan atmosfer seru dan menghibur bagi para pemainnya.

Selain keseruan permainan slot yang ditawarkan, bonus jackpot yang melimpah menjadi daya tarik utama bagi para pemain OVOPLAY yang ingin meraih keberuntungan besar. Melalui fitur keamanan canggih, pengguna dapat melakukan transaksi dengan tenang tanpa khawatir data pribadi mereka akan disalahgunakan. BRIN menekankan pentingnya investasi dalam riset dan inovasi di bidang sains lingkungan dan teknologi ramah lingkungan untuk mencapai tujuan perlindungan masyarakat.

Pentingnya kerjasama lintas sektoral dan internasional juga menjadi fokus BRIN dalam mengatasi dampak perubahan iklim. Sebagai pemimpin lembaga yang menegakkan hukum dan memberantas korupsi, keterlibatan Ketua KPK dalam dugaan pungli menjadi ironis dan menimbulkan kekhawatiran terhadap integritas lembaga tersebut. Perlu dicatat bahwa setiap individu dianggap tidak bersalah sampai terbukti secara sah dan meyakinkan di pengadilan.

Alasan Mengapa Kalian Harus Memilih OVOPLAY

Pertama-tama, kemudahan dalam melakukan transaksi menjadi faktor utama yang membuat OVOPLAY diminati. OVOPLAY juga menyediakan layanan streaming film dan serial TV yang dapat diakses dengan mudah. Kepraktisan, keamanan, beragam promo menarik, dan fitur hiburan yang lengkap menjadikan OVOPLAY slot online gacor terpercaya sebagai aplikasi yang mampu memenuhi kebutuhan beragam penggunanya.

OVOPLAY tidak hanya menjadi platform pembayaran digital terkemuka, tetapi juga telah menjadi slot pilihan utama bagi masyarakat Indonesia yang ingin menikmati berbagai layanan dengan mudah dan nyaman. Keberhasilan OVOPLAY sebagai slot pilihan masyarakat Indonesia tidak lepas dari berbagai keunggulan yang dimilikinya. Kementerian juga membuka ruang partisipasi masyarakat melalui berbagai forum diskusi dan konsultasi publik, guna memastikan bahwa suara dan aspirasi masyarakat terdengar dalam proses pembuatan kebijakan ini.

Dengan adanya penyelarasan antara UU ITE dan KUHP, diharapkan masyarakat Indonesia dapat merasakan perlindungan hukum yang optimal, terutama dalam menghadapi tantangan dan risiko di slot online. Selain itu, layanan pelanggan yang responsif siap membantu para pemain dalam mengatasi berbagai masalah atau pertanyaan yang mungkin timbul. Bagi para penggemar slot online, bergabung dengan OVOPLAY adalah pilihan yang cerdas.